« July »
Locations of visitors to this page

Powered by blojsom

Radovan Semančík's Weblog

Monday, 16 July 2012
« Enterprise Identity Management | Main | How I Lost My Faith »

Clouds are everywhere. We got pretty much used to that buzzword. Open API Economy is quite new. But it is almost the same. What seems to be the mantra behind "Cloud" and "Open API Economy" is: Do not do it yourself. Scrap whatever solution you have now and replace it with the magic service from the cloud. It is a perfect, easy, cheap and simple solution. Or ... is it?

What most of the proponents of cloud APIs have in mind is this:

The cloud companies publish an API that makes their services available to the consumers. Consumers do not need to understand the intricacies of how the service is implemented. They just consume the API which is far simpler. So far so good. It is quite easy to do for one service. Or two. But how about eight?

Poor little Alice will need to create (and maintain) a lot of client software. Oh yes, it is still easier than hosting all these services internally. Unless, of course, the internal implementation can be customized to specific needs that Alice has. And unless the internal implementation can expose a more suitable interface. Anyway, the complexity will not magically go away with migration to the cloud. It can even complicate the things much more, especially if somehow each of the cloud services has a different mechanism for security, consistency, redundancy, ...

There is also one deadly trap in the clouds: vendor lock-in. It is not the regular vendor lock-in as is known today. This is much worse. If you have a software and you stop paying your annual support fee nothing really happens. You still have the right to use the software. The software may break or you may need to change it. But there may be several companies that can do this for you. But the situation is quite different in the cloud. If you stop paying for the cloud the service will stop. Immediately. You have no right to use the service any more. You may own the data, but how do you migrate it to a different service? The APIs are not compatible, data formats are not compatible and processes are not compatible. Actually cloud service is inherently difficult to customize therefore the usual software replacement strategy is almost useless. Once the idea of a cloud sinks in the service fee may quite easily become a ransom.

To make things even worse current cloud services are not really cloud at all. They are not lightweight, not omnipresent and they cannot really move that well either. They are more like petrocumuli. They are dangerous.

The problem behind all of this is the basic misunderstanding of the purpose of the interface in the software systems. Interface, thats the "I" in API, yet too many people designing APIs do not understand the principles well enough. One of the purpose of the interface is to hide implementation from the clients. That's what the API folk gets right. But there is more. Much more. The reason why we want to hide the implementation is because we want to have a freedom in changing that implementation. The changes may happen in time, e.g. a new version of the service implementation. But they may also happen in space, e.g. a switch to an alternative service implementation. And it is the later case that cloud providers seems to ignore. Accidentally? Or is there a purpose?

For an example see how Microsoft reinvents semantic web using its own Graph API. The experience taught me that whatever Microsoft does it does it with a purpose.

So, what is the solution? It is too early to tell. We do not know enough about distributed systems yet. But one thing is almost certain. The use of cloud APIs should be similar to the use of interfaces in any well-designed software systems. When applied to cloud it might look like this:

We know this concept well. It is concept of a protocol: an agreement between communicating parties that abstracts the actual implementation. And that's it. The cloud APIs should not really look like APIs. They should be protocols.

Posted by rsemancik at 3:01 PM in Software

Add your comment:
(not displayed)
Generate another code

Please enter the code as seen in the image above to post your comment.
Your comments will be submitted for approval by blog owner to avoid comment spam. It will not appear immediately. Also please be sure to fill out all mandatory fields (marked by asterisk). This ... ehm ... imperfect software does not have any error indication for missing input fields.


[Trackback URL for this entry]